Debate Skills

Big Questions Debate for Beginners: How to Help Your Teen Prepare

•6 min read
← Back to Blog

Most debate events argue about policy. Big Questions argues about ideas. Past resolutions have included "Objective morality exists" and "Science leaves no room for free will." If your teen loves a dinner-table argument that never quite ends, this event was built for them.

Big Questions is a debate event run by the National Speech and Debate Association (NSDA) and supported by the John Templeton Foundation. The details below come from the NSDA's Big Questions judge training (September 2025) and its student format manual. Tournaments can set their own rules, so check the invitation before your teen's first round.

This Season's Resolution

Big Questions uses one resolution for the whole school year. For 2026-27, NSDA members voted for: "Technological progress has surpassed humanity's ability to use it ethically." The NSDA reports it won 74% of the coach vote and 57% of the student vote.

The resolution is a comparison, so your teen has to explain how they measure both halves before claiming one has passed the other. AI will come up in many rounds, but it is only one technology.

How a Round Works

A student can compete alone or with a partner, so a round can be one-on-one, two-on-two or even two-on-one. Partners split the speeches. Some tournaments allow only one entry type.

Here is the order of a round:

1. Constructives: 5 minutes each, Affirmative first. These are prepared speeches that lay out each side's case. 2. Question segment: 3 minutes. The Affirmative asks the first question, then both sides question each other freely. 3. Rebuttals: 4 minutes each, answering the other side and rebuilding their own case. 4. Question segment: another 3 minutes. 5. Consolidations: 3 minutes each, narrowing the debate to the arguments that matter most. New arguments are discouraged. 6. Rationales: 3 minutes each, explaining why their side won. No new arguments.

Each side also gets 3 minutes of prep time. Some older tournament packets list 2-minute rationales and 5 minutes of prep, so read the invitation. Over a tournament, students debate both sides several times.

The Rule That Surprises Beginners

In most debate events, a negative team can win by showing the other side has not proven its case. Big Questions asks for more. The NSDA's format manual says the Negative should argue that the resolution is actually false, as if it were the Affirmative on the opposite statement. A Negative who only pokes holes in the Affirmative's case has done half the job.

What Judges Are Deciding

Big Questions judges are often volunteers from the community, and the ballot asks one question: "Who did the better debating?" Judges weigh mainly the arguments, and may also consider delivery.

Because the topics touch deeply held beliefs, judges write down which side they personally agree with before the round, then write reasons each side could have won on the ballot. Both steps are there to keep a judge's own views out of the decision.

The Mistakes First-Time Debaters Make

Quoting an expert instead of explaining. The format manual says an author making an assertion is not, on its own, a reason it is true. Every argument needs a claim, a warrant (why it is true) and an impact (why it matters).

Defining nothing. On this year's resolution, "ethically" can mean very different things. The debater who defines their terms clearly often decides what the round is about.

Forgetting citations. NSDA evidence rules ask debaters to say at least the author's last name and the year of publication out loud, and to have the full citation ready if asked.

What Helps at Home

1. Ask for the case in one sentence. If your teen cannot say why the resolution is true (or false) in one sentence, the case is not ready. 2. Make them define the terms. Ask, "What does using technology ethically look like, and how would we know?" 3. Argue the side they dislike. Have them give two minutes for the side they personally disagree with. They will have to do it at every tournament. 4. Run a three-minute question segment. Ask short, honest questions. Good answers are one or two sentences. 5. Be the community judge. After a practice speech, tell them which argument you remember. If it is not the one they meant to win on, keep working.

How TalkMaze Fits

TalkMaze offers 1-on-1 online public speaking and debate coaching for students ages 5 to 17. Big Questions rewards the student who can define an abstract idea plainly and defend it to a stranger in real time. A weekly session is where that gets built: a coach can test your teen's definitions, play a tough opponent in the question segment, and time every speech until the rationale is tight. Our debate program coaches students in the event they compete in. Founder Ghalia Aamer is a national debate competitor, TEDx speaker and Princess Diana Award recipient, and every TalkMaze coach trains on the method she built for organizing an argument fast and defending it live. For the other NSDA resolutions this season, see our guide to the 2026 NSDA debate topics, or compare with Public Forum for beginners.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Big Questions debate?

Big Questions is a National Speech and Debate Association debate event on topics where science and philosophy meet. Students debate one resolution for the whole school year.

What is the 2026-27 Big Questions resolution?

The 2026-27 Big Questions resolution is "Technological progress has surpassed humanity's ability to use it ethically," chosen by NSDA member vote.

Can you do Big Questions debate alone or with a partner?

Both. A student can compete alone or with a partner, so rounds can be one-on-one, two-on-two or two-on-one, though a tournament can limit entries to one type.

How long is a Big Questions round?

A Big Questions round has 30 minutes of speeches and two 3-minute question segments, plus 3 minutes of prep time per side under the NSDA's current judge training. Some tournaments use slightly different times.

The Bottom Line

Big Questions rewards students who define their terms, explain their reasons and stay calm when the questions get hard. If your teen has opinions about this year's resolution and wants to turn them into a winning case, book a free assessment. A coach will help them build the first one.

Ready to find your child's voice?

Book a free assessment session today.

Book a free assessment