Giving the reviewReceiving it

Performance review conversation coaching

Rehearse the review from whichever chair is yours.

A review is a spoken conversation with a written form behind it. Managers practice saying the hard part plainly. Employees practice describing their year, hearing criticism and asking for specifics.

What is performance review conversation coaching?

Performance review conversation coaching is rehearsal for the review meeting itself, for the manager who delivers a review or the employee who receives one. At TalkMaze for Adults you say your side out loud in 1-on-1 40-minute sessions with a qualified human coach, who plays the other chair and gives feedback on each attempt. The coaching is on the spoken conversation, and HR and legal questions stay with you and your HR team.

The form has five parts. Each one is a sentence somebody has to say.

Annual review, spoken versionA sample form. Your own review supplies the content.
  1. 1. Opening

    The manager says

    I want to go through the year with you: what went well, one thing to change, and what comes next.

    The employee says

    Before we start, may I give you my own summary of the year in two minutes?

  2. 2. What went well

    The manager says

    The client handover in March worked because you wrote everything down before you left.

    The employee says

    The result I am proudest of is the audit. We closed it three weeks early.

  3. 3. What needs to change

    The manager says

    Four reports came in late this year. I need to hear about a delay before the due date.

    The employee says

    Can you give me one example, so I know exactly what you mean?

  4. 4. The rating

    The manager says

    Your rating is "meets expectations". Here is the reason in one sentence.

    The employee says

    I expected a different rating. What would the next level have looked like this year?

  5. 5. Next steps

    The manager says

    By June I would like you to run the monthly report on your own.

    The employee says

    So the two things to work on are deadlines and the monthly report. Is that right?

Three moments no form covers.

Your coach sits in the other chair and plays them, so you have said your next sentence out loud before the meeting. The written review, the rating and questions of HR policy or employment law stay with you and your HR team.

  1. Silence after the hard sentence

    Managers practice stopping once the criticism is said, and waiting for the other person to answer.

  2. A rating you did not expect

    Employees practice one calm question before they respond to the rating itself.

  3. Tears, anger or a flat "fine"

    Your coach plays each reaction in turn, and you practice the sentence that comes next.

Topics from the program

Know Your Audience · Say It in Sixty Seconds: S.E.E. · Stories That Prove a Point · Closings and the One Key Message · Thinking on Your Feet · Your Voice and Personal Style

Questions about performance review coaching

I am a manager giving reviews for the first time. Can I rehearse each one?
Yes. Bring your points for each person, with names removed if you prefer, and say each review to your coach. The six-session program covers one goal over six weeks, which suits a review season.
I expect a critical review. What do we practice?
You practice three things: a two-minute summary of your year, a question that asks for a specific example, and a closing line that repeats back what you heard. Your coach delivers the criticism in several tones, so you have answered each of them out loud already.
Will the coach tell me what rating to give or how to word the written review?
The coach works on the spoken conversation: what you say, in what order, and how you respond to what comes back. Ratings, written reviews and anything governed by company policy or employment law stay with you and your HR team.
Can I practice the self-assessment, where I describe my own year?
Yes. You tell your year as three results, each in a sentence or two, and your coach times it. Then you take the follow-up questions a manager is likely to ask about each result.

Start with a 15-minute call.

Tell us what you speak for and what is coming up. It is free, and there is nothing to buy on the call.