Guide

How to Choose a Public Speaking Coach

Seven questions to ask before you hire a coach, what a good first session looks like, the red flags, and a short script for the intro call.

Last reviewed · 11 min read · By the TalkMaze for Adults team

Anyone can call themselves a speaking coach. A licensed clinical profession such as speech-language pathology has a named credential behind it: the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association describes a graduate degree, supervised clinical experience and a national exam. We are not aware of a single equivalent credential that covers speaking coaches, so the title alone tells you little.

That leaves you to judge a coach by how they work. This guide gives you a way to do that in one conversation. It is written for a working adult with something on the calendar: a presentation, an interview, a pitch, or a new role with more meetings in it. TalkMaze for Adults is a coaching service, so we have a stake here. The questions are the ones we would want you to ask us too.

What kind of speaking help do you need?

Before comparing coaches, decide which kind of help fits your situation. The four common options do different jobs.

What it is good atWhere it fits
Private 1-on-1 coachCorrection in the moment on your own material, at your paceA specific event on your calendar, or a habit you cannot fix alone
Live group courseA set curriculum and practice with other learnersGeneral skills on a set curriculum, alongside other learners
Practice clubA regular audience and many chances to stand upRegular practice in front of a group over months
AI speaking appCounts of pace and filler words, any time of dayRehearsing alone between live sessions

Clubs, courses and apps all help with practice. In our experience a private coach is the faster route because of the feedback: one person listens to you alone, stops you at the exact sentence that went wrong, and has you say it again. If your event is weeks away, that speed is what you are paying for. Our cost guide lists published prices.

Pick the kind of help first: a private coach for a specific event or a stubborn habit, and a club, course or app for general practice around it.

The seven-question coach check

Ask these seven questions on an intro call or by email.

  1. What will we work on for my event? Describe the presentation, interview or meeting and ask how the sessions would be planned around it. A good answer names topics and an order. A weak answer describes the same program for everyone.
  2. How much of each session will I spend speaking out loud? Speaking is a physical skill, and you build it by doing it. Ask for a rough share of the session. Listening to theory for most of the time is a lecture.
  3. How do you give feedback? Look for a coach who gives one or two specific corrections about the task, then has you repeat the passage. The research on feedback supports this. A meta-analysis by Kluger and DeNisi (1996) of 607 effect sizes found that feedback improved performance on average, yet over one-third of feedback interventions reduced it, and that feedback worked less well as attention moved toward the self and away from the task.
  4. Will I have the same coach every session? A coach who heard you last week knows what you were working on. Ask whether you are matched to one person and what happens if they are away.
  5. How will we know I have improved? Ask for something you can hear or see: a recording from the first session and one from the last, a short written assessment, or a named skill that is checked each week.
  6. What do I do between sessions? One session a week leaves six days without the coach. Ask what practice is set, how long it takes, and whether there are tools for rehearsing alone.
  7. What is the total cost, and what are the terms? Get the total price, the number of sessions, what each session includes, whether sessions expire, and the rescheduling notice. Ask the coach for the terms in writing.

The seven-question coach check covers your event, speaking time, feedback, coach continuity, proof of progress, practice between sessions, and total cost and terms.

What does a good first session look like?

The first session tells you most of what you need to know. In our experience, a strong one follows a recognizable order.

  1. A short conversation about the goal. The coach asks what the event is, when it is, who will be in the room and what has gone wrong before. This takes minutes.
  2. You speak early. Within the first part of the session you deliver something real: the opening of your presentation, an answer to an interview question, or an update you would give in a meeting.
  3. The coach names one or two things. You hear what worked and the one change that would help most. The coach picks a priority and leaves the rest for later.
  4. You try again straight away. You repeat the same passage with the change, and the coach tells you whether it landed. This repeat is where the learning happens.
  5. You leave with a plan. You know what the next sessions will cover and what to practice before the next one.

In a good first session you speak within the first few minutes, get one or two specific corrections, repeat the passage, and leave with a plan.

Red flags when hiring a speaking coach

These are our views from coaching. None of them proves a coach is poor, and each is worth a follow-up question.

  • A guaranteed result. No coach controls how your interview or pitch turns out. A promise of a job offer, a promotion or a fear that is gone for good is a sales line.
  • No interest in your event. If the coach does not ask what you are preparing for, the sessions will be generic.
  • Feedback about you as a person. "You lack presence" gives you nothing to do. "Finish the sentence before you look down at your notes" does. This matches the feedback research cited above, where attention on the self went with weaker results.
  • Mostly talking, little practice. If you spoke for a small share of the trial session, expect the same later.
  • Unclear prices or terms. You should be able to get the price, what it includes and the cancellation terms in writing before paying.
  • Pressure to buy a large package today. A good coach lets you start small or take a day to decide.
  • Claims to treat anxiety or a speech disorder. Those are clinical matters for a doctor, a therapist or a speech-language pathologist.

Be cautious with guaranteed results, feedback about your personality, little speaking time, and prices you cannot get in writing.

A script for the intro call

Ten to fifteen minutes is enough if you arrive with your questions written down. You can read these out as they are.

  1. "I have a [presentation, interview, meeting] on [date]. How would you plan the sessions before then?"
  2. "In a typical session, roughly how many minutes would I spend speaking?"
  3. "Can you give me an example of the kind of correction you would make, and what you would have me do next?"
  4. "Would I work with you every time, or with different coaches?"
  5. "How would I be able to hear the difference between my first session and my last?"
  6. "What would you ask me to practice between sessions, and for how long?"
  7. "What is the total price, what does it include, and can I have the rescheduling and expiry terms in writing?"

Ask every coach the same seven questions on the intro call and write the answers down so you can compare them.

Where TalkMaze for Adults fits

TalkMaze for Adults offers 1-on-1 online speaking coaching for work, covering presentations, interviews and meetings, in weekly 40-minute sessions with a qualified human coach and AI practice tools between sessions. Here is how it answers the seven questions, in the same order.

  1. Your event. Sessions are built around the event on your calendar. The program is a training plan of 24 topics in four blocks (Foundations, Structure, Persuasion, At work), and the coach picks the topics for your goal.
  2. Speaking time. Every session is 1-on-1, so the speaking time is yours, and every topic is trained with drills, out loud.
  3. Feedback. Sessions are live and 1-on-1 with a qualified human coach, so corrections come while you are speaking and you try again straight away.
  4. Same coach. You work with the same coach throughout.
  5. Proof of progress. On the 6 and 12 session programs you are assessed at the start and the end, and both recordings are available to download for 90 days.
  6. Between sessions. AI practice tools are included for rehearsing between sessions.
  7. Cost and terms. One session is $150, 6 sessions are $810 and 12 sessions are $1,500, or 3 monthly payments of $500, in US dollars (Canadian dollars in Canada). That is $125 to $150 a week. Details are on the pricing page, and the intro call is the time to ask for the rescheduling and expiry terms in writing.

Every session is 1-on-1 and focused on your speaking. If you want one coach working on your event with you, the first step is a free 15-minute intro call by phone, and the script above works on it.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose a public speaking coach?
Choose a public speaking coach by asking seven questions before you hire: what you will work on for your event, how much you will speak in each session, how feedback is given, whether you keep the same coach, how progress is shown, what you practice between sessions, and the total cost and terms.
What qualifications should a public speaking coach have?
Look for evidence of how the coach works, because we are not aware of a single license or credential that covers speaking coaches. Useful evidence includes experience coaching adults for the kind of event you have, a clear method they can describe, and a first session where you can see the feedback for yourself. A clinical credential such as the CCC-SLP belongs to speech-language pathologists, who treat disorders, which is a different service.
What should I ask a speaking coach on an intro call?
Ask how the sessions would be planned around your event, how many minutes you would speak in a session, and for an example of a correction they would make. Then ask whether you keep the same coach, how you would hear your progress, what practice is set between sessions, and the price, what it includes and the rescheduling terms.
What are the red flags when hiring a public speaking coach?
The main red flags are a guaranteed result, no questions about your event, feedback about your personality in place of specific corrections, very little speaking time for you, and prices or terms that are not given in writing. Pressure to buy a large package on the first call is another. A coach who claims to treat anxiety or a speech disorder is working outside coaching.
Can a public speaking coach help with anxiety?
A coach can help with ordinary speaking nerves by giving you a prepared structure and repeated practice, which many people find steadying. A coach does not treat anxiety. If fear of being judged has lasted six months or more and interferes with daily life, which is how the National Institute of Mental Health describes social anxiety disorder, a doctor or therapist is the right person to see. Our guide to fear of public speaking at work covers this in more detail.
Is a private coach better than a group course?
A group course gives you a set curriculum and practice with other learners, which suits general skill building when no date is pressing. In our experience a private coach is the faster route for a specific event or a habit you cannot fix alone, because all of the session is spent on your speaking and the corrections are yours. TalkMaze for Adults is 1-on-1, and the first step is a free 15-minute intro call by phone.

Sources

  1. Kluger and DeNisi (1996), The effects of feedback interventions on performance, Psychological Bulletin 119(2), 254-284 (abstract)
  2. National Institute of Mental Health: Social Anxiety Disorder, More Than Just Shyness
  3. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association: speech-language pathologists (scope and the CCC-SLP credential)

Start with a 15-minute call.

Tell us what you speak for and what is coming up. It is free, and there is nothing to buy on the call.